Snapped Front Wishbone Bottom Bolt

Moderators:davidr, BigCatXJS, dhdove

SimonR

Member
Posts:578
Joined:Mon Jan 05, 2009 1:55 pm
Snapped Front Wishbone Bottom Bolt

Postby SimonR » Thu Oct 06, 2005 5:06 pm

Hi there,

Well, it was going so well until this happened: In April this year I bought KXI4239, a Sapphire Blue XJS 3.6 Manual which had just undergone a complete rebuild.

Having had it for four months, I was driving along a quiet road in Cambridgeshire which had just been 'traffic calmed' (surely you should be able to do 30 Mph in a 30 Mph area without having your chin spoiler torn off?). Anyway the speed bumps came as a surprise to me so I braked quickly and steered to the right to align my car in the centre of the road and there was a loud bang followed by a lurch to the left. I was only doing about 15 Mph at the time.

Turns out that I managed to snap the front offside bottom wishbone bolt that attaches the wishbone to the subframe. The wishbone dropped down at the back (I guess the bolt shifted forwards when I braked) and the wheel was sticking out at about 60 degrees. Luckily the tyre didn't come into contact with any bodywork - it was literally 1cm away from the front wing... Eek.

I was wondering if it's a common thing with the XJ-S. The chap at my local garage, who is an ex-Jaguar man, said he'd never heard of it before. The car is currently having all of the bolts in the suspension tested and replaced where necessary to prevent this sort of thing happening again!

Should get it back just in time to put it in the garage for the winter ;) Seriously though, I can't wait to get my Cat back it's been away for a month so far.

Thanks for your replies

SimonR

Member
Posts:578
Joined:Mon Jan 05, 2009 1:55 pm

Snapped Front Wishbone Bottom Bolt

Postby SimonR » Wed Oct 19, 2005 10:20 am

Woo Hoo, last night I finally got my Jag back after a month and a half at the garage.

I think I worked out what happened: when the bloke was rebuilding the car, he couldn't get the correct bolts so made a couple up instead rather than wait a month for Jag to supply them.

Still, I soon forgot about the cost of the repair when I got back into it and took it for a long drive through the Fens last night. It truely is a wonderful beast.

Martin
Posts:33
Joined:Sun Sep 25, 2005 2:06 pm

Snapped Front Wishbone Bottom Bolt

Postby Martin » Wed Oct 19, 2005 12:56 pm

Simon - good to hear you're back on the road - and still alive! Your experience illustrates the risks with amateur restorers.

User avatar
Mark_B
Posts:199
Joined:Wed Sep 07, 2005 7:05 pm
Location:Luton
Contact:

Snapped Front Wishbone Bottom Bolt

Postby Mark_B » Thu Oct 20, 2005 2:36 am

Wow I just read this. I was just going to say, sounded like defective or grossly overtightened bolt. I beleive these ones are HT ones, not MS. That part of the car has to survive an enormous hammering and it's a good thing you had nasty speed humps near you to proof test suspension with at safe speed, that sleeping policeman seems to have spared you a situation that doesn't bear thinking about, from now I'll look at humps in a different way.
XJ-S 3.6 230k miles +

Martin
Posts:33
Joined:Sun Sep 25, 2005 2:06 pm

Snapped Front Wishbone Bottom Bolt

Postby Martin » Fri Oct 21, 2005 1:57 pm

Mark i couldn't agree more. By similar reasoning I always like my brakes tested by a heavy booted examiner on the MOT rolling road. If they're going to burst I'd rather they do it there than when I'm trying to avoid a 32 ton juggernaut.

SimonR

Member
Posts:578
Joined:Mon Jan 05, 2009 1:55 pm

Snapped Front Wishbone Bottom Bolt

Postby SimonR » Fri Oct 21, 2005 3:51 pm

Yeah, I'd certainly go along with that! The XJ-s must have tonnes of momentum at motorway speeds so it'd be nice to know it will stop OK.

Interestingly the suspension is better than ever now. It used to lurch to the right under heavy braking but now pulls up completely straight, which is nice.

One thing that several people have said to me is that these sorts of failures don't often happen at high speed. I guess I can see how it's true: think of the forces in the suspension as you brake and turn the wheel at low speeds. It has to put more load on the suspension than turning at, say, 70 mph. I guess I could have come unstuck when trying to brake and steer suddenly to avoid an accident or something on the motorway though.

I once sat in a traffic jam on the M5, trying to join the M6 and as I finally got to the slip-road there was a lot of gravel from the central reservation all over lane three and a solitary wheel, with shock absorber and hub still attached and then about 50 metres further down there was a Ford Escort on its roof....

I think it'd take a lot to do this to an XJ-S (what with it being a lot heavier and having a lower centre of gravity) but it still wouldn't have been very good for me or the car if it had happened, say about ten minutes earlier on the A14, between speed cameras.


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests