Well, I like the Arden 2+2. A very brave styling attempt that Jaguar did actually try as a one-off (an XJ6C roof with Daimler fluted grills/badges too if I recall correctly). The Arden looks just as elegant, equal to the Eventer Series 2 (big bumper) especially.
I wouldn't quite want to give my right arm for one of these late Eventers (there are only 15 apparently), but it would be a close call! There is an excellent Belgian web-site about these models, go find (
http://www.lynxeventer.com/en/). Lots of info. there too.
Anyway, I like the buttresses and agree they make the XJS what it is. But that hasn't stopped me fullfilling an apprentice ambition I had for a hatchback XJS, keeping the roof un-altered. This is nearing completion in my garage now (only trim to do), so it will be out there soon. Watch various spaces particularly the Jaguar Enthusiast for an article hopefully later in the year. I might even let the forum in on it first and hope to be at the Jaguar Day at Bosworth in July.
I could tease you with a photo. but that would only ruin the surprise. People who've seen it think it really works and looks like the factory did it, which was the intention. A one-off (not counting the Zantia rear ended version).
If poeple didn't try things, we would be able to comment on what's good or bad. To my mind, they each have a place and the rare ones sometimes become more sought after, just like JaguarSport variants will always aave a place and a certain value higher than standard model, to those collecters who have the desire. Jaguar history is littered with these limited builds; Coombes, Ecurie Ecosse, Lynx, Lister, Paul Bailey, Paul Banham etc. When you see one, it promotes discussion at least!
Enjoy life and do what you want. I know I've been very brave with my rather dishy XJS Coupe (photo's in the forum gallary - not converted!!), but it's my indulgence and makes standard ones rarer still (as does racing them as a lot get trashed - I've been there and seen them done!).
Regards,
JaguarMike