Page 1 of 2
Insurance - what's reasonable this year?
Posted: Thu Feb 02, 2012 8:54 pm
by almcl
Joined the ranks of the X350 owners with a 2.7TDVi last week.
Initially insurance co said just £40 to change...
Renewal notice arrived today (only had a month to run) and it's for a whopping £1100+. This (IIRC) is almost 4 times the amount they were charging for my 4.0 XJS and seems a bit steep. I know the car is worth a bit more, but nothing else has changed much, performance is similar, I am using it just the same way, I am still the same age (OK, one year older- 61) so why the hike?
What are you guys paying? And, if you have a good deal, who is it with?
Re: Insurance - what's reasonable this year?
Posted: Thu Feb 02, 2012 9:10 pm
by J44EAG
Al,
Peter James told me that premiums increased 35% last year and the same again this year. Graham confirmed this. That reflects in the high premiums we are all experiencing. Fortunately, I was able to knock £150 off this years premium as I discovered that a locked secure boat yard compound is better than unlocked. Shame I didn`t find that issue last year.
Red Star have my business this year via PJ. Apparently they capped their hike to 20%. Even so, I`m paying nearly double compared to two years ago. PJ beat even the on line quotes.
The days of cheap insurance appear to have gone.
mike
Re: Insurance - what's reasonable this year?
Posted: Thu Feb 02, 2012 10:45 pm
by almcl
Thanks, Mike.
I was thinking I might give Peter a ring in the morning, he fixed a good deal for my wife's X-type.
Your experience confirms it.
Re: Insurance - what's reasonable this year?
Posted: Thu Feb 02, 2012 11:26 pm
by robv12
Yep PJ for me too, Julie is my girl there, WONDERFUL service, known her for years right back into my days with the TSSC and Footman James
current premium, £1054, runs out April, so expecting a hike, 3 named drivers, aged 58, 60 and 62, not saying which is me!!, 8 cars, 1 x X350 XJR, 2 x X300R, 1 x V12 40, 4 x various odd XJ40's, all agreed value, unlimited mileage, three claims, three windscreen claims as well, loaded occupation to boot, third party cover driving any other car too, handy for moving cars around before and after purchase
PJ have my daily hack Insurance as well, a tad under £600 , just renewed, Mondeo on tractor juice, four named drivers all in loaded occupations, business use, carrying goods and samples, one claim, one windscreen
hope this helps
Re: Insurance - what's reasonable this year?
Posted: Fri Feb 03, 2012 8:27 am
by almcl
Indeed it does, Rob.
I might ask them to look at the cost of the X-type and the X350 on a dual car policy - they are our daily drivers.
Is that what you have yours on?
Re: Insurance - what's reasonable this year?
Posted: Fri Feb 03, 2012 10:12 am
by robv12
Al, I have a multi vehicle policy for my Jaguars, I swap and change at will through the year as cars come and go, I think this insurance year we have had at least 6 changes, no charge if the value of the replacemnt is lower, and a pro rata fee to renewal date if it is higher, usually circa 15/20 quid as most of my cars are worth so little in monetary terms, a quick call, I even have PJ in my favourites on my phone!!, and it is all done in a split second, docs arrive next day
to give you a clue, when we bought our 06 XJR, the additional premium was £48.51 from August 26th 2011 through to renewal at April 28th 2012
In the paperwork for the XJR was the previous owners insurance renewal at a whopping £1300
My Mondeo is a sole vehicle policy, but tailored to what we need at the brewery , thats the loaded occupation for some reason
I have tried eleswhere, to no avail, no one seems to come close on price, but price is not the be all and end all, it is the service and understanding of my needs and wants I get at PJ , this does it for me everytime
Re: Insurance - what's reasonable this year?
Posted: Fri Feb 03, 2012 10:28 am
by barrywi
I am 65 with a 2007 TDvi garaged ,living in the Lake District and my last premium was £260 fully comp protected bonus. Just used Confused to get the best quote and with a fairly well known company. I change every year for the best deal as I find if you don't they sneak the money back the second year. Companies always give you better value if you are a new customer.I limit my miles to 4000 a year so maybe that is why it is cheap
Re: Insurance - what's reasonable this year?
Posted: Fri Feb 03, 2012 11:53 am
by J44EAG
Area post code makes a huge difference to premiums. The South Coast being more frantic that the Scottish Borders will be loaded accordingly.
Similarly, if I were to live in London, the premium would be increased above that of the South Coast.
A couple of years back, I used a typical on line insurance comparative site and plumbed in different post code areas but using identical driver and claims history. The differences were certainly significant. I recall Manchester and Bradford based quotes were eye watering.
So for me down here, J44 costs me around £650 fully comp, £350 excess, including break down home start, legal and protected on ten years NCD at an age of 53 and with sole driver use, non business.
Voluntary excess chosen also significantly impacts on premiums for obvious reasons.
Mike
Re: Insurance - what's reasonable this year?
Posted: Sat Feb 04, 2012 12:24 pm
by ptjs1
Al,
Welcome to the world of X-350s! Huge value at the moment, imo.
I do think that insurance prices can be problematic for X-350 owners. Notwithstanding the overall insurance premiums increase in recent years, X-350s seem to be an enigma and one can't use other Jaguar models as a benchmark.
When I got my 4.2 last year, I was horrified at the initial quotes. In a good postcode, albeit not garaged and with unlimited mileage and only 3 years NCB to use on this car, I was getting quotes at £900 - £2600! That surprised me even for a Group 19 car.
My other Jaguar broker, Adrian Flux, quoted me a best of £900 to stay with them (XJS is about £230!) I asked them to swap the 12 year NCB on the XJS for the spare 3 year NCB but they said it wouldn't really make any difference.
After using a range of specialist telephone agents to get indicative quotes, one said that "Adrian Flux are prepared to consider meeting your best quote". So bizarrely I ended up being referred to my own brokers who had originally said they "definitely couldn't get below £900".
Using a bit of poetic licence when asked "what is the best quote you've had", I finally got them to agree to £570. A lot of effort but I saved a lot of money.
I'm not sure why X-350s seem to get much higher quotes than X308s. It may be the aluminium & bonded repair costs or the increased performance, or perhaps the fact that it's really just too new to be really embraced by the specialist / classic market?
We all know that insurance is a bit of a game now. Loyalty counts for nothing and an industry that rewards the acquisition of new customers implies that one almost has to move company each year to be cost-effective.
I hope you get a good result and I'm sure you'll enjoy the car. Notwithstanding that I love my other cars, my 4.2 really is a quantum leap forward in terms of refinement, performance and stunning fuel economy!
Paul
Re: Insurance - what's reasonable this year?
Posted: Sat Feb 04, 2012 10:10 pm
by almcl
Thanks, Paul.
We will see. I've been with the present company for a while so it won't hurt to shop around.
As to the car, its performance (diesel) isn't much different to the XJS. With the exception of the mpg, of course. What really surprises is the ride. Perhaps the 19" wheels and to-me-at-least low profile tyres are what make the difference but, unlike my DD6 and previous series XJs, every imperfection in the road is unerringly transmitted. The handling is crisp and precise, and the seats and everything else are very comfortable, but harsh is not an inappropriate description...
Re: Insurance - what's reasonable this year?
Posted: Sun Feb 05, 2012 10:54 am
by robv12
Al, agreed, we swapped out our 18 inch wheels on our 3.0 350 for 19 inch XJR ones, the ride quality dipped considerably, the current XJR is on 19's as well and is quite pointy and jiggly, I can live with it though
so there is a set of 4 18 inch wheels with tyres here if you wish, pm me if interested
Re: Insurance - what's reasonable this year?
Posted: Sun Feb 05, 2012 11:26 am
by ptjs1
Al,
Aboslutely agree with Rob. Wheel & tyre size seem to make big differences on these cars. I'm running my 4.2 on 18" and it seems a really nice compromise of feel with comfort. Try test driving an X-350 on 18" whels and then you might want to consider a wheel change.
Paul
PS my car was pretty useless in 6" of fresh snow last night. Still it eventually got me home safely, which is what matters!
Re: Insurance - what's reasonable this year?
Posted: Sun Feb 05, 2012 12:33 pm
by jeff1954
I agree with Barry. I to use the compare sites every year.This year it was £307 with legal protection and protected bonus.
Jeff.
Re: Insurance - what's reasonable this year?
Posted: Sun Feb 05, 2012 2:53 pm
by SHunt
Hi Al . With reference to insurance, I purchased my Super V8 in November and managed to get fully comp insurance for £495 with Admiral . This is with no No Claims Bonus as we use that on my boys Nova . It was also cheaper if I had my partner added as a named driver , its garaged overnight and limited to 5000 miles a year.
Steve
Re: Insurance - what's reasonable this year?
Posted: Thu Feb 16, 2012 2:08 pm
by almcl
Just to close this out, I managed to get insurance for less than half what F-J wanted.
It certainly pays to shop around.
And I didn't have to give away my email address, mobile phone number, home phone number, and all the other spam-attracting nonsense that the so-called price comparison websites insist on. Peter James did OK!