Page 1 of 1
glow plugs won't turn off
Posted: Tue Mar 30, 2021 10:34 am
by grahamkelley
Hi, can anyone help me, I have a 2009 2.0d X Type where the glow plug loom connection had melted and the loom wire burnt through. I replaced it to find power wouldn't turn off to the glowplugs, and the new connection became very hot. The glowplug light on the dash goes off as you would expect, but a test light showed no interruption to power to the glowplugs, just carried on with the engine running for several minutes until the connection started to smoke. I then replaced the relay R10, no difference. Is there a control module anywhere or does control come direct from the ECU? For the time being I have removed the relay, car drives fine. Thanks, Graham
Re: glow plugs won't turn off
Posted: Tue Mar 30, 2021 10:37 pm
by Astromorg
The wiring diagrams show that Relay R10 has a permanent battery supply for the actual gloplug power supply. The R10 operating coil has a power supply that is switched on by relay R7 whenever the ignition is On and the R10 relay should connect/disconnect the supply to the gloplug when the ground connection for the R10 operating coil is connected or disconnected by the ECU itself, depending on whether it wants the gloplugs On or Off.
So it would seem to me that your problem is that that ground connection is being permanently grounded, either by a faulty ECU, or, maybe a damaged wire insulation allowing an unwanted grounding. The wire in question is shown as an Orange wire with a Green tracer, but finding it in the overall harness might be tricky as it comes from the base of the Power Distribution Fuse box in quite a bundle leading to the ECU.
Fortuitously, that Orange/Green wire is the only one of that colour/tracer combination going to the ECU, but be careful as it has a Green wire with Orange tracer immediately beside it in the 120-way connector to the ECU. Easy to mix up!
With R10 removed, note the position of Pin 2 on the base of the relay. That is the one that is connected to the Orange/Green wire, so its socket in the fuse box can be used as a test point to to see if it's grounding at all times - which it shouldn't!
Re: glow plugs won't turn off
Posted: Thu Apr 01, 2021 3:42 pm
by grahamkelley
Thanks for your help Astromorg, I had a look today, started by disconnecting the supply cable from the loom, test light connected then ignition on, and power was on for 30 seconds, relay clicked, power off. I then connected the supply cable to the loom but with the insulated post unbolted and in mid air, same result. Next I bolted the insulated post down, same again. So far so good, relay off after 30 secs every time, so I then started the engine, relay won't turn off now! I then disconnected the supply cable from the loom again, started the engine and relay won't turn off, so it's not the glowplugs or loom grounding. Now I'm stumped, why the difference between engine started or not? Any more advice will be gratefully received.
Re: glow plugs won't turn off
Posted: Thu Apr 01, 2021 6:30 pm
by Astromorg
Following those results, I think you should be able to narrow down the cause now.
Remove relay R10 and identify where its Pin 2 fits into the fuse box. With ignition Off, measure the resistance between that pin position and any suitable ground point. It should read either zero resistance or open circuit. Either would be OK at this time.
With the relay still not fitted, measure that resistance and turn on the ignition. I would expect it to read zero for 30 secs and then go open circuit - 0 resistance
With the relay still not fitted, measure that resistance again and start the engine. It should read zero for 30 secs again and then go open circuit, though from your reported results it's likely to stay at 0 resistance, equivalent to keeping the relay R10 On and providing power to the gloplug.
If so that would seem to indicate the problem being with the ECU noting it behaves as expected when the engine is not running. In that case you could try a Hard Battery Reset; disconnect the battery at the ground cable, join the disconnected ground cable to the positive terminal for a few seconds (this does not create a circuit) and then reconnect as normal. When the battery has been disconnected and connected, the stored idle and drive values contained within the engine control module (ECM) will have been erased. The ECM must relearn the idle and drive values and with a bit of luck that might include the gloplug parameters. You will, of course, have to reset the clock, radio code and window one-touch feature.
Fingers crossed for you

Re: glow plugs won't turn off
Posted: Sat Apr 03, 2021 9:33 am
by grahamkelley
Thanks very much for helping, it's much appreciated. I went through the test sequence on plug 2 just now, still live when engine running, so I did the hard restart but sadly just the same. Two thoughts occur, either having the ecu reflashed or trying to find a timer relay. Don't you just love cars....
Re: glow plugs won't turn off
Posted: Sat Apr 03, 2021 2:56 pm
by Astromorg
When you say ' I went through the test sequence on plug 2 just now, still live when engine running' do you mean by 'still live' that the relevant socket in the fuse panel remains at 0 ohms, or are you saying you're getting a voltage reading there? (Which you shouldn't)
Just to be sure we're on the same wavelength, a resistance reading from the relay pin 2 receptacle in the fuse box to any convenient ground on the engine or body should change from 0 ohms to Open Circuit after about 30 secs of the engine running.
If it still comes down to the suspect ECU, rather than re-flashing in hope, it might be worth checking out an ECU repair facility of which there are many on line if you search. Eg
https://the-ecu-doctor.co.uk/
Re: glow plugs won't turn off
Posted: Mon Apr 05, 2021 4:54 pm
by grahamkelley
Going through your tests, the multimeter showed a resistance at R10 pin 2 socket then going to 1, open circuit, at each stage of test, then with engine running the resistance remained, so I put a test light from pin 2 to ground, which showed live.
What I'm baffled by is that all is fine until the engine is running - if a grounding problem it should surely be constant engine on or off, so I can only imagine the fault lies with the ECU. Are there any sensors which may be giving the ECU false information? I think your suggestion of ECU repair is sound, so I think I'll have a chat with them.
Thanks once again for your help.
Re: glow plugs won't turn off
Posted: Mon Apr 05, 2021 7:16 pm
by Astromorg
I don't want to abandon you Graham, but I fear I'm coming to the end of any roads I can take from here to get you sorted without your getting the ECU itself tested.
The lighting of the test light from socket 2 in the fuse panel position for R10 is strange! That point should only ever be open circuit or a full ground - it should never have a voltage on it with the relay removed. Without access to the design and construction of the ECU I can't explain it other than probably a breakdown of the relevant electronic switching arrangement - maybe because the voltage with the engine/alternator running is greater than the battery alone.
Removing the ECU is not too difficult if you know what's needed! If you need any guidance, send me a pm with your email address and I'll gladly forward you the Jaguar directions.
Re: glow plugs won't turn off
Posted: Tue Apr 06, 2021 6:44 pm
by grahamkelley
You're not abandoning me, I'm grateful for your time and help! Thanks, Graham