Hi
Can someone please advise me on the best engine oil to use on a Mark 2, 3.8 litre, 1965 car. It has a leak from the rear crank shaft seal but doesn't use much oil over a year. I have been using Millers Classic 20w 50 mineral oil but this is getting difficult to obtain. Has any one had any experience of changing to a synthetic oil. I look forward to some feedback. Thanks Keith Johnson
Engine Oil
Moderator:Aceman
Re: Engine Oil
Valvoline VR1 Racing mineral oil can be purchased direct - advantage-racing.co.uk
Re: Engine Oil
After much heart searching I decided in the end to stick with classic mineral oil for my 1971 4.2 XK engine. I was persuaded that the attributes of the classic mineral oils better match the engine characteristics than modern oils designed for modern engines.Has any one had any experience of changing to a synthetic oil
I use Castrol Classic XL 20W-50 - in 20 litre drums from Opie Oils.
Robbie
1996 4 litre XJS Celebration 2+2
Daimler Sovereign S1 4.2 1971
Daimler Sovereign S1 4.2 1971
Re: Engine Oil
This post summed it up for me and was instrumental in persuading me to stick to "classic" oils.
Robbie
Hope this may help.Posts: 5Joined: Fri Nov 11, 2016 9:28 amContact:
Contact wimgohres
Re: Synthetic oil
Report this post
Quote
Postby wimgohres » Mon Jul 24, 2017 10:18 am
I have been advised not to use synthetic oil by the seller of my MK2 and by my very experienced garage. Because of the lower viscosity my car would start to leak.
Castrol has below text on their website, which I think is quite plausible. This means that the oil should be mineral of semi -synthetic.
The formulations required for modern vehicles are very different from those needed for older vehicles. Oils for modern engines comply with the latest API ratings of SN/CF and specific ACEA and OEM specifications dealing with fuel efficiency, extended drain intervals and aftermarket exhaust treatment systems and are specifically designed for the modern engine needs.
A classic car engine however, can have the opposite characteristics with cork/graphite/rope seals, low pressure gear driven oil pumps, larger oil galleries with greater dependence on "splash" and "cling" lubrication, lower revving with larger machine clearances. Such a widely different engine design can demand a totally different lubricant and the Castrol Classic Oils range offers formulations for older vehicles that have been specially blended for the work they have to do.
Inadequate detergent can result in gums and lacquers clinging to the hotter engine components, and blocking oil galleries – But, too much detergent can cause a build-up of metallic ash in the combustion chambers and piston crowns . In older engines with traditionally high oil consumption, this can cause detonation and pinking.
In older engines where the carbon has built up over a number of years detergents can have a scouring effect, causing the carbon to flake off, blocking up oil galleries and spray jets. High levels of detergent can also "wash" traces of carbon from seals and gaskets, revealing oil leaks where the carbon itself is creating a seal.
Insufficient anti-oxidant and the oil can quickly thicken during high temperature motoring, with large amounts of carbon, gum and varnish clogging oil galleries, filters and piston rings.
Anti-wear additives are added to ensure that if the oil film between moving parts breaks down prematurely, metal to metal contact and irreparable engine damage is prevented.
Engine internals can become pitted with corrosion and rust from acids and water vapour formed during combustion. With the correct corrosion inhibitors, the components are well protected.
Special dispersant additives prevent soot, wear metals and the by-products of combustion settling out in the sump and other areas of the engine, and forming a thick sludge that can block filters and oil ways.
If there is inadequate pour point depressant the oil ceases to flow at low temperatures, with excessive strain on the oil pump or in certain cases, oil starvation on start-up causing complete failure of the lubrication system.
Castrol Classic Oils are specially formulated in the style of the original products, but using the most appropriate and carefully balanced additive technology to provide the best protection and performance for your classic engine.
Robbie
1996 4 litre XJS Celebration 2+2
Daimler Sovereign S1 4.2 1971
Daimler Sovereign S1 4.2 1971
Re: Engine Oil
I use Morris lubricants from Shrewsbury. Always works well and they do 'traditional' 20/50 which seems to suit the car by minimising leakage which seems to increase with modern oils.
I agree with Robbie about the use of old cars. Never tried Millers but I thought it was readily available and at their recent 'Hull' weekend I had understood they had explained the importance of the correct lubricant being used.
Regards,
I agree with Robbie about the use of old cars. Never tried Millers but I thought it was readily available and at their recent 'Hull' weekend I had understood they had explained the importance of the correct lubricant being used.
Regards,
Paul V
Mk2 3.8
Nissan Micra K13
Porsche Macan S
Mk2 3.8
Nissan Micra K13
Porsche Macan S
Re: Engine Oil
Hi Robbie,Has any one had any experience of changing to a synthetic oil
Very wise choice in staying with traditional oils for your older engine's.
Years ago when I used my motorcycles as everyday transport I had a 1981 Harley Davidson FXWG and thought it would be good to use a synthetic engine oil,to cut a long story short the H.D. engine uses roller bearings for the connecting rods and with the synthetic oil they stopped rolling and decided to slide causing them to go flat.
After that I went back to the straight oil's I used before,40 in the winter and 50 in the summer,so good choice Robbie.
Hi PPV,I use Morris lubricants from Shrewsbury
I use Morris Oils and have never been disappointed with any of their oil's.I first came across them when I used a local agricultural engineer to do some welding for me and he was an agent for Morris,also being agricultural the price is subsidised.
Good oil anyway.
By the way,sold all motorcycles now as hands hurt to much due to freezing winter commuting,should of listened to my mates who used to tell me to put them away for the winter and I used to say to them you want to "man up a bit",now I'm suffering.
Enjoy your Jaguar's and Daimler's.
Andy
2011 X351 3.0d LWB
Colour: Ultimate Black Metallic With Black/Ivory Piping Interia
2007 X-Type 2.2d Sport Premium Estate
Colour:Liquid Silver With Charcoal Interia
Colour: Ultimate Black Metallic With Black/Ivory Piping Interia
2007 X-Type 2.2d Sport Premium Estate
Colour:Liquid Silver With Charcoal Interia
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest
